PERJANJIAN PENYERAHAN WILAYAH UTARA BORNEO 1865, 1877 DAN 1878: TINJAUAN AWAL TERHADAP PERBANDINGAN INTIPATI PERJANJIAN
North Borneo Territory Surrender Agreements 1865, 1877 And 1878: A Preliminary Review of The Comparison of The Contents in The Agreement
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51200/manu.v32i1.2937Keywords:
Utara Borneo, penyerahan, Kesultanan Brunei, Kesultanan Sulu, BNBC, North Borneo, concession, Brunei, SuluAbstract
Makalah ini merupakan satu usaha untuk membahaskan semula pandangan mengenai perjanjian-perjanjian 1865, 1877 dan 1878 tentang penyerahan wilayah utara Borneo oleh Kesultanan Brunei dan Kesultanan Sulu kepada British North Borneo (Chatered) Company (BNBC) yang diwakili oleh Overbeck dan Alfred Dent. Sumber primer sedia ada telah diinterpretasi semula oleh penulis dalam perspektif yang baharu. Dihujahkan bahawa perjanjian penyerahan wilayah utara Borneo pada tahun 1865, 1877 dan 1878 yang dilakukan oleh Kesultanan Brunei dan Kesultanan Sulu ini telah menghasilkan suatu peristiwa yang dilihat daripada dua dimensi yang berbeza di dalam pensejarahan Borneo Utara. Kajian lepas banyak diteluri dengan sumber dokumentasi barat sehingga mengabaikan sumber tempatan yang dianggap bersifat berat sebelah terutamanya apabila Kesultanan Brunei menafikan penyerahan sebahagian wilayah utara Borneo kepada Kesultanan Sulu. Namun pada masa yang sama Kesultanan Sulu tetap meneguhkan pendiriannya bahawa telah berlaku penyerahan tersebut kepadanya dengan menggunakan perjanjian 1878 sebagai pengesahan. Dapatan kajian menunjukkan bahawa perjanjian penyerahan wilayah utara Borneo 1865, 1877 dan 1878 berlaku disebabkan oleh kegagalan Kesultanan Brunei dan Kesultanan Sulu untuk mengawal politik pentadbiran di tanah jajahan masing-masing sehingga terpaksa melakukan penyerahan wilayah mengikut terma perjanjian Barat bagi memastikan kedua-dua buah Kesultanan tersebut mampu untuk terus survival. Kajian ini juga mendapati bahawa kepelbagaian tafsiran terhadap terjemahan kandungan perjanjian juga turut memberikan implikasi besar terhadap kefahaman masyarakat sehingga menimbulkan pelbagai spekulasi dan pertikaian yang berterusan sehingga kini. Justeru itu, makalah ini akan cuba untuk menganalisis perbandingan perjanjian penyerahan Borneo Utara pada tahun 1865, 1877 dan 1878 bagi merungkaikan kebenaran peristiwa sejarah antara Kesultanan Brunei dan Kesultanan Sulu sehingga membawa kepada berlakunya penyerahan wilayah ini secara total kepada BNBC.
This paper is an attempt to the explanation of the cession of the northern territory of Borneo by the Sultanate of Brunei and the Sultanate of Sulu to the British North Borneo (Chatered) Company (BNBC) represented by Overbeck and Alfred Dent. Existing primary sources has been reinterpreted by the authors in a new perspective. It is argued that the treaties of surrender of the northern territories of Borneo in 1865, 1877 and 1878 made by the Sultanate of Brunei and the Sultanate of Sulu have produced an event seen from two different dimensions in the history of North Borneo. Past studies have been heavily influenced by western documentations so that ignoring local sources is considered biased especially when the Sultanate of Brunei denies the surrender of a part of North Borneo territory to the Sultanate of Sulu. Yet at the same time the Sultanate of Sulu maintained its position that there had been the surrender of the northern province of Borneo to it by using the 1878 treaty as confirmation. The findings of the study showed that the northern Borneo territorial agreements of 1865, 1877 and 1878 occurred due to the failure of the Sultanate of Brunei and Sulu to control administrative politics in their respective colonies so that they had to surrender the territories in accordance with the terms of the Western agreement to ensure continuous survival. This study also found that the variety of interpretations on the translation in the content of the agreement also has significant implications on the understanding of society, leading to various speculations and disputes up to this day. Therefore, this paper will attempt to analyze the comparison of North Borneo cession agreements in 1865, 1877 and 1878 to unravel the truth of historical events between the Sultanate of Brunei and the Sultanate of Sulu leading to the total surrender of this territory to BNBC.
References
Sumber Pertama (dokumen dan surat khabar)
CO 874/2. (1865). Brunei Grant of North Borneo to Moses (U.S Consul). 11 August.
CO 874/2. (1865). Temenggong of Brunei's Grant to Moses. 11 August.
CO 874/2. (1865). Sultan's Comission of Torrey as Raja. 24 November.
CO 874/4. (1865). Memorandum Agreement between Joseph William Torrey,
Thomas Bradley Harris, Asing, Apong. Hong Kong. 25 October.
CO 874/5. (1865). Sultan's Commission of Torrey as Raja. 24 November.
CO 874/6. (1865). Brunei Grant of Banguey Island to Moses. 29 November.
CO 874/13. (1875). Temenggung Grant to Torrey. 21 June.
CO 874/29. (1881). Indenture between Joseph Torrey and Alfred Dent. 15 January.
CO 874/32. (1881). Indenture between Alfred Dent and the British North Borneo Provisional Association. 6 July.
CO 874/54. (1877). Grant by Sultan of Brunei of Territories from Paitan to Sibuku River. 29 December.
CO 874/54. (1877). Grant by Pengiran Temenggung of Brunei of Provinces of Kimanis dan Benoni. 29 December.
CO 874/54. (1877). Grant by Sultan of Brunei of Territory the Sulaman River to the River of Paitan, 29 December.
CO 874/54. (1878). Grant by Sultan Sulu of Territories and Lands on the Mainland of the Island of Borneo. 22 January.
CO 874/54. (1898). Grant of Menggatal, Mengkabong, Api-api, Sembulan, Napas, Tembalang. 23 March.
CO 874/54. (1877). Commision from Sultan of Brunei Appointing Gustavus Baron De Overbeck Maharajah of North Borneo, and Raja of Gaya and Sandakan. 29 December.
CO 874/54. (1865). Sultan's Commission of Torrey as Raja, 24 November.
FO 12/33. (1866). Torrey to Thomas Harris Bradley Harris. Hong Kong. 2 May.
FO 71/1. (1761). Dalrymple's First Treaty With Sulu. 28 January.
FO 71/1. (1763). Dalrymple's Second Treaty With Sulu. 19 September.
FO 93/46/25. (1871). Convention between Great Britain and the Netherlands for Settlement of their mutual relations in the Island of Sumatra. Signed at the Hague. 2 November.
FO 71/18. (1885). Protocol between Great Britain, Germany and Spain, Signed at Madrid, 7 March. North Borneo Herald. (1883, 1 March).
Buku dan Artikel
Abdul Karim bin Haji Abdul Rahman. (2014). Meruntuhkan empayar Brunei KMXIX: satu kajian dari sudut ekonomi. Kementerian Kebudayaan. Belia dan Sukan Bandar Seri Begawan: Pusat Sejarah Brunei.
Allen, J. De V., Stockwell, A.J & Wright L.R (pnyt.). (1981). A collection of treaties and other documents affecting the states of Malaysia 1761-1963. Vol.I. Jil.2. London: Oceana Publications.
Awang Othman Bin Haji Mat Don. (2010). KMXVII-XIX: An analysis of the history of its decline. Jurnal Darussalam. Jil.10. 91.
Cesar Adib Majul. (2010). Muslim in the Philipines. Retrospective Issue 1. Vol. 46. 1-2 . Asian Studies: University of the Philippines Press.
Eko Prayitno Joko. (2015). Isu pemilikan wilayah pantai timur Sabah: Satu penelusuran daripada sudut sumber sejarah, Kota Kinabalu: Universiti Malaysia Sabah.
Hamdan Aziz dan Syahrin Said. (2016). Tuntutan Kesultanan Sulu terhadap Sabah: sorotan dari perspektif sejarah dan perundangan. Melayu: Jurnal Antarabngsa Dunia Melayu. Jil. 9. Bil.2. 279-294.
Najeeb, M. S. (2013). The history of Sulu. Manila: Bureau of Public Printing. H.G.Keith. (1980). The monograph of the Brunei museum journal the United States Consul and the Yankee Raja. Brunei Darussalam: The Brunei Museum.
Ian Black. (1983). A gambling style of government the establishment of the chartered company's rule in Sabah 1878-1915. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
Irwin, G & Mohd Nor Ghani dan Noraini Ismail (pnyt.). (1986). Borneo abad kesembilan belas. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
Mat Zin Mat Kib. (2017). Sejarah pengurusan pertikaian sempadan antara Britain dan Belanda di pantai timur Borneo Utara dari tahun 1878 hingga 1915. Tesis Doktor Falsafah. Universiti Utara Malaysia.
Mohd Jamil Al-Sufri. (1994). Brunei di tengah-tengah nusantara. Seminar Sejarah Brunei. Bandar Seri Begawan: Pusat Sejarah Brunei. 19-20.
Mohd. Jamil Al-Sufri. (2002). Tarsilah Brunei II zaman kegemilangan dan kemasyuran. Bandar Seri Begawan: Pusat Sejarah Brunei Kementerian Kebudayaan Belia dan Sukan.
Nik Anuar Nik Mahmud. (2001). Tuntutan Filipina ke atas Sabah. Bangi: Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.
Noble, L.G. (1977). Philippine policy toward Sabah a claim to independence. Arizona: The University of Arizona Press.
Raffles, T.S. (1830). The history of Java. Vol.2. Singapore: Oxford University Press.
Saunders, G. (1994). A history of Brunei. United States of America: New York.
Singh, D.S.R. (2003). The making of Sabah 1865-1941 the dynamics of indigenous society. Kuala Lumpur: Universiti Malaya.
Tarling, N. (1971). Britain, the Brookes & Brunei. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press.
Tregonning, K.G. (2007). Under chartered company rule: North Borneo (1881- 1946). Kuala Lumpur: University Of Malaya.
Wright, L.R. (1998). The origins of British Borneo. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
All right reserved. No part of this publication can be reproduced without prior written permission of the copyright holder. The written permission of the copyright holder must be obtained before any parts of this publication is stored in a retrieval system of any nature.
Requests for permission to duplicate an article, review or part of this journal should be addressed to the Chief Editor, MANU, Centre for the Promotion of Knowledge and Language Learning, Universiti Malaysia Sabah, Jalan UMS, 88400 Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia.
Total Views: 4036
| 
Total Downloads: 1417
